1. Terrel Owens 14% of votes
2. Tony Romo 7% of votes
T-3rd. Albert Haynesworth 5%
T-3rd. Mark Sanchez 5%
5. Eli Manning 4%

Again voted by 239 NFL players.

I don't think Eli is over rated. He is one of the better QBs in the game, but everyone has a bad game at times.

I think people expect QBs to be the gunslinger type, which Eli isn't.

Terrell Owen's age is catching up and the numbers are decining but still a good receiver. Not sure who's actually overating him but certainly not myself. Just giving him credit

Tony Romo is a good qb. He chokes at times in big games but there is probably 25 other teams out there that would welcome him in as their starter. (not overated imo.)

Haynesworth. Is still a great DT. Put him in the right system and keep him happy and your defense will win games for you. (not overated)

Mark Sanchez has turned out pretty decent this year. I wouldn't overate him because he's just not that good yet. It's hard to overate an average QB or any other position for that matter.

Eli Manning. Well I never actually heard that much good stuff about him coming from the talking heads.
If people are saying he's great than I disagree.
If their saying he's a top 10 QB than I agree.
And no I'm not going to try and come up with a top 10 list.

TD I agree with you word for word on Romo, Owens, and Sanchez. Haynesworth isn't worth being the highest paid defensive player. Way to inconsistent and he should be able to play in any system with that tag so I think overrated.

Eli. Well, He's been overrated since college.